Planetary Nebulae
Planetary Nebulae
Planetary Nebulae
     HOME          LISTS I & II / IR          DOCUMENTATION          DATA GATHERING                                       
     SPECTROSCOPIC CONFIRMATIONS
Balance sheet of amateur PN spectroscopic observations
  September 30th 2020 - Lionel Mulato  PN.net Actuality   
Fig1: number of PN candidates spectra performed by amateurs per year since 2011
Introduction

In the late 2000s amateur astronomers began to discover a great number of new Planetary Nebula (PN) candidates. The first PN candidates were discovered by chance by astrophotographers while taking deep narrow band images of the sky. But the number of discoveries has significantly increased as amateurs started to search PN trough professional wide field surveys such as SHS, IPHAS, WISE and now VPHAS+.

The status of newly discovered objects remains uncertain until a spectrum is performed. Even if narrow band images leave little doubt about the fact that an object is a PN, an optical spectrum is necessarily needed to confirm its nature. And it can take years to get a confirmatory spectrum from a professional observatory.

This situation was a bit frustrating for amateur discoverers. In France there is a fairly small but very active amateur community of spectroscopists. Owing the rising number of new candidates discovered by amateurs, an amateur spectroscopic observation program started in 2015.


Number of observed PN candidates

On 18 September 2020, the number of PN candidates spectra performed by amateurs is about 230. Figure 1 shows the number of observations per year from 2011 to September 2020.

First spectra were acquired back in 2011. The observations became more intensive from 2015 and increased significantly in 2019. More than 70 spectra are now performed per year, exclusively in the northern hemisphere. The southern hemisphere will soon be covered by 2SPOT.


Status of PN: Possible, Likely, True PN or mimic ?

All our data is ingested into HASH PN database produced by Prof. Quentin Parker and now maintained by Dr. Andreas Ritter at The University of Hong Kong : Parker, Bojicic & Frew 2016. The status of observed PN candidates is updated in HASH accordingly by Prof. Quentin Parker.

Figure 2 shows the different statuses of the observed objects (status on September 2020) and the origin of their discovery (amateur or professional discovery).

There are 3 major statuses for PNe :
- True PN which means that the object is confirmed as a PN. The optical spectrum must show clear evidence of PN characteristics. But this is not the only condition to be met. The confirmation requires the compliance of multiple criteria based on the analysis of multi-wavelength surveys (X, UV, optical, NIR, MIR, radio...),
- Likely PN which means at this point that the object is still a PN candidate, but with a good probability of being a True PN. The object needs more investigations (deeper spectrum, better S/N ratio spectrum...),
- Possible PN which means that the object might be a PN but further investigation is needed.

Sometimes PN candidates turn out to be objects completely unrelated to PNe. These objects are PN mimics categorized as "other" in the figure 2 (below) and are mainly HII regions, emission line galaxies, supernova remnants, emission line stars... or simply objects of unknown nature based on available data.

The amateur spectroscopic observations are not only focused on amateur discoveries but also on professional discoveries which lack an optical spectrum. The origin of the discoveries is somewhat controversial. Several recent discoveries attributed to amateurs have been in fact already noticed years ago by professionals. But their discoveries are yet unpublished.

Figure 2 shows that amateurs have helped to confirm nearly 130 True PN both from amateur or professional PN candidates lists. This is an appreciable amount (5%) of the total number of known True PNe (~2600 True PN in HASH Database). Amateurs observations can also provide a good first estimation for deeper further investigations.
Fig2: status in HASH Database (September 2020) of observed PN candidates from amateur or professional lists
Where and who ?

Figures 3 shows the annual number of performed spectra per observatory.

The main data providers are observatories based at Cornillon (L. Mulato) and Porspoder (P. Le Dû), both using a rather small telescope aperture (20 cm) with a low resolution spectroscope.

A lot of spectra have also been performed during the spectro-parties at l'Observatoire de Haute Provence by C. Buil, S.Charbonnel, O. Garde, P. Le Dû, T. Lemoult, L.Mulato and T. Petit.

Every year we are allowed to use professional telescopes with a larger aperture (up to 1m) at Calern, Astroqueyras or Pic du Midi observatories. The observational team is made up of a large number of amateur astronomers : G. Arlic, P. Bazar, A. Brémond, C. Buil, S.Charbonnel, P. Dubreuil, O. Garde, B. Guégan, V. Lecoq, P. Le Dû, T. Lemoult, M. Leveque, A. Lopez, J-P. Nougayrede, J. Souchu.
Fig3: number of spectra of PN candidates performed by amateurs per year and per observatory
Sources and links
Liste de tous les articles: Cliquer ici
L'article sur le site de Lionel Mulato: Night Photons
Planetary Nebulae
Respect capital letters and spaces !
Example: PN-G 262.4-01.9 or DeGaPe 32
  About the article...
Date: September 30th 2020
Author: Lionel Mulato
Category: PN.net Actuality
Article id: 51
All the articles: click here
Associated articles:
- Mise à jour des listes I et II (11)...
- Mise à jour des listes I et II (10)...
- Les nouvelles découvertes de Dana Patchick sur Pl...
- Mise à jour des listes I et II (9)...
- Mise à jour des listes I et II (8)...
Planetary Nebulae .net
Contacts: - in charge PN and applications: Pascal Le Dû (ledu@shom.fr)
- webmaster: Thomas Petit (petittom@gmail.com)
© Planetary Nebulae .net - 2020 - All rights reserved
The Planetary Nebulae .net website offers all the useful and practical information about the planetary nebulae (candidates), how to apply for a new discovery and how to confirm the candidates. If you would like to contribute to the website, please visit the Data Gathering page and contact us.
Contributors: Pascal Le Dû - Thomas Petit - Olivier Garde - Nicolas Petit - Trygve Prestgard - Jean-Baptiste Feldmann - Lionel Mulato - Sakib Rasool - Dana Patchick